AI Overviews put a generated answer above the results for a large share of searches. For site owners the immediate question is simple: did this take my traffic, and if so, what do I do about it. The answer depends almost entirely on what kind of query brought people to the page.
The queries that lost the most
Anything with a short, factual answer. Definitions. Conversions. "What is a favicon." "How long should a meta description be." These were never valuable traffic in commercial terms, but for a lot of blogs they were the bulk of the pageviews, and losing them makes a dashboard look alarming.
Also hit: thin comparison and listicle content that existed mainly to occupy a keyword. If a page's entire contribution can be compressed into three sentences by a model, it will be, and the click goes away.
The queries that barely moved
- Anything with buying intent. Nobody hires a web developer from a paragraph. Queries that end in a decision still end in clicks.
- Local searches. "Near me" behaves differently, and the map results still dominate.
- Branded searches. Someone looking for you specifically is going to your site.
- Anything needing a real opinion, a real price or real evidence. A generated summary cannot show your work.
The uncomfortable part
If a large share of your traffic came from informational queries with no commercial intent, some of that is not coming back, and chasing it is a poor use of effort. The honest response is not to grieve the pageviews. It is to check whether that traffic was ever producing anything. A lot of the time it was a number that looked good in a monthly report and converted at close to zero.
What to actually do
Audit by intent, not by volume
Sort your pages by the enquiries and sales they generate, not the sessions. Whatever sits at the top of that list is what to protect and extend. If a page drove three thousand sessions and no enquiries in a year, losing its clicks is not the problem worth solving this quarter.
Make the surviving pages worth a click
A summary cannot reproduce your pricing, your process, photographs of your work, a calculator, a template someone can download, or a case study with specifics in it. Pages that carry that sort of thing keep earning clicks because the answer is genuinely not liftable.
Write for the question behind the question
"How much does a website cost" gets summarised. "What we charge for a five-page business site, and what changes the number" does not, because it is a claim only one business can make.
Stop relying on one channel
This is the part nobody enjoys hearing. A business whose enquiries come only from organic search has a structural risk that has now shown up twice in three years. An email list you own, a review profile that brings referrals, and a Google Business Profile that works are not glamorous, and they do not get rewritten by somebody else's product decision.
A reasonable expectation
For most small business sites, the sessions number falls and the enquiries number holds roughly steady. If both fell, the cause is usually something other than AI Overviews, and it is worth an actual audit before you rewrite anything. We cover that in our SEO service, and there is a practical companion piece in our on-page checklist.
Have a project in mind?
Tell us about it and we'll get back to you within one business day.